Skip to main content

Transparent Appointments for an Independent Judiciary 

WOLA

Team WOLA

Renewal of the Supreme Court of Justice in Venezuela: Organizations call for Candidate Evaluations to Be Conducted with Maximum Transparency and Based on Merit, Suitability, Independence, and Gender Parity.

Caracas, November 18, 2026.—The undersigned organizations present our recommendations regarding the new phase of the Supreme Court of Justice (TSJ) renewal process, stemming from the agreements of the Dialogue Table, which begins with the closing of the nomination period.

We appreciate that, unlike in previous appointments, this process includes diverse political sectors and representatives of civil society in the selection of justices. We also highlight the existence of a public timeline, the formation of a Council for the Verification of Credentials and Requirements with a majority of independent members, and—for the first time in more than two decades—the publication of an evaluation rubric. We believe these are encouraging signs that must be protected and strengthened. With the same conviction, we note that there are aspects of the process that can be improved and corrected through certain measures that will ensure those selected for the position of justice on the Supreme Court of Justice (TSJ) are independent legal professionals of recognized integrity and competence.

Proposals for the Next Phase

The evaluation of requirements, merits, and suitability must be conducted in accordance with the Constitution of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela and applicable international standards. These standards require that the process and all its components be transparent; that selection be based on merit as the guiding criterion; that objective and pre-established criteria be applied; that the verification of integrity and independence be carried out without subjectivity; that decisions be substantiated; and that there be mechanisms for challenging decisions and meaningful participation or oversight by civil society, as well as a guarantee of gender parity. Within this framework, we urge the Judicial Nominations Committee (CPJ), the Verification Council, the National Assembly, and the Dialogue Table to adopt the following measures, which are feasible within the current timeline:

  1. Publish key information about the process: the CPJ’s operating regulations, the résumés of at least those who have passed the initial verification of requirements, and the scores obtained following the review of credentials. This information helps build trust in the process and enables adequate public oversight and scrutiny; furthermore, it makes effective challenges possible, if warranted.
  2. First verify eligibility requirements, in accordance with Article 263 of the Constitution, specifying the requirements for each route of entry and the Chamber to which the candidate is applying. This verification must be conducted prior to and separately from the assignment of points, so that no score compensates for noncompliance. The Verification Council can play a key role in this task.
  3. Adjust the scoring scale so that the minimum requirements serve as the starting point and additional experience receives higher scores; evaluate judicial careers in accordance with Article 255 of the Constitution; and recognize, in a balanced manner, independent professional practice and teaching.
  4. Verify the political independence of candidates prior to their nomination. Those aspiring to be judges must be legal professionals of recognized competence and integrity, as well as politically independent from political parties prior to their candidacy. Resigning from a political party or a public office held on its behalf—whether submitted after nomination or pre-selection, or worse yet, after appointment—does not demonstrate independence, as this must be a pre-existing condition. To this end, the CPJ and the Verification Council must publish in advance objective and precise criteria regarding party affiliations, party positions, and relevant political roles, and require a declaration of such ties and interests in a proportionate manner, without excluding anyone for lawful activities that pose a low risk to judicial impartiality or for their legitimate work in defending human rights.
  5. Incorporate objective criteria to assess the suitability, integrity, and good character of candidates, allowing for an evaluation of their ethical conduct, impartiality, and professional track record through individualized assessments based on reliable and verifiable sources, as well as full respect for due process, including the right to be informed of and contest any allegations. Likewise, clear rules must be established regarding the scope and use of background checks, mental health assessments, and digital reputation reviews, and it must be ensured that no one is excluded because of their opinions or their legitimate work in defense of human rights. The criteria must include an express exclusion of individuals responsible for human rights violations documented by international protection mechanisms or human rights organizations, and such exclusion should be carried out ex officio, even in the absence of challenges.
  6. Adopt mechanisms to guarantee gender parity as a cross-cutting principle that is integrated with the criteria of merit and suitability, to ensure balanced representation in the final composition of the TSJ.
  7. Ensure transparency in the interviews by designing and publishing the evaluation criteria in advance, with differentiated and specific indicators, as well as by ensuring that evaluators form balanced panels with sufficient representation of politically independent profiles. The interviews must be broadcast live or, at a minimum, allow for public participation, and must also permit the virtual participation. These should contribute to the scrutiny of candidates’ personal backgrounds, based on criteria that allow for the investigation of potential inappropriate situations, conflicts of interest, and risks of favoritism or bias as perceived by a reasonable observer.
  8. Ensure an effective mechanism for citizens to challenge candidacies, as a means of civil society participation that allows for the assessment of the integrity and independence of the nominees and prevents the inclusion of candidates involved in serious human rights violations. To this end, the timeframe for filing challenges must be clear and sufficient; a procedure must be established for submitting reliable information, even in the absence of a criminal conviction, while guaranteeing the nominee’s right to be informed of and respond to the challenges filed against them; and each challenge must receive a reasoned and public response.

This process represents a long-awaited opportunity to begin restoring judicial independence in Venezuela. We therefore call on the relevant authorities —the National Assembly, the Judicial Nominations Committee, the Council for the Verification of Credentials and Requirements, and the Dialogue Table— to conduct the upcoming phases in strict accordance with constitutional and international standards of judicial independence, transparency, objectivity, citizen participation, and gender parity, thereby ensuring that appointees are selected based on merit, suitability, and independence.

Signatory organizations:

Access to Justice AlertaVenezuela

Aula Abierta

Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL)

Caleidoscopio Humano

Espacio Público

Due Process of Law Foundation (DPLF)

Ideas for Democracy

Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA)

Education and Action Program on Human Rights (PROVEA)

Robert C. Ethel Kennedy Human Rights Center

Share